Fiscal policy in the emerging economy: an excerpt from Kaushik Basu
In an excerpt from An Economist in the Real World, Kaushik Basu, Chief Economist at the World Bank, on fiscal deficits from Kautilya’s Arthashastra to Keynes and India after 2008.

As Chief Economist at the World Bank, Kaushik Basu relives his days serving as chief penny pincher to the Government of India. An excerpt...
Fiscal policy is concerned with the management of the government’s budget. A central focus of this policy is the fiscal deficit, that is, the gap between the total expenditure of the government and its total earnings.

Most governments spend more than they earn. Hence, the fiscal deficit is usually positive. We usually refer to the fiscal deficit as a percentage of the national income or GDP. As with most budgeting exercises, the original aim was to heed the advice that grandmothers give — “don’t live beyond your means,” be responsible spenders, and keep the gap between what you spend and what you earn, basically, the fiscal deficit, as low as possible. As an aside on history, this advice actually goes much further back than our grandmothers.
What is not always appreciated is that the ancient Indian classic, the Arthashastra, written by Kautilya in approximately 300 BC and famed as a brutally candid treatise on statecraft, is largely a treatise on fiscal policy, with detailed advice on how the emperor should manage the deficit of the state, acting both on the side of raising revenue and containing expenditure.
True to Kautilya’s reputation as a forebear of Machiavelli, some of the methods he describes to raise revenue are rather unnerving. Kautilya (1992, 272–273) observes how common people are extremely gullible and, should the state find itself in sufficiently dire fiscal state, it can exploit this gullibility. Thus, he points out, money can be collected by “exploiting an unnatural happening, such as an unseasonal flower or fruit, by making it into a divine phenomenon [or] using secret agents to frighten people into making offerings to drive away an evil spirit.” And if there are people “not taken in so easily,” “secret agents should give unbelievers an anaesthetic in water and blame their condition on a curse of the gods.”
I had better stop here for fear that this book may fall into the hands of contemporary political leaders. This view, held from ancient times, that deficits ought to be contained either by curbing expenditure or raising revenue, changed a little less than a hundred years ago, with the arrival of John Maynard Keynes and the Great Depression, when it was realised that overspending also had its virtues. During a depression, when private firms and ordinary individuals spend less, it was realised that the government could step in to compensate for this by overspending or, in other words, by running a larger fiscal deficit.
This was the Keynesian prescription and President Roosevelt and his advisers in the United States stumbled upon this even before Keynes’s classic book came out in 1936. When the global financial crisis hit the world in 2008 and quickly spread to the entire world (with the possible exception of North Korea), we saw a virtual policy revolution. Almost all nations coordinated and used fiscal policy as a weapon. In other words, the fiscal deficit was expanded in most nations. India was in a very good position to do so, since its fiscal policy had been very tight until 2008. That meant there was scope for fiscal expansion. This fiscal stimulus helped. The economy’s growth, which had slumped to 6.7 per cent in 2008–2009, shot up to nearly 9 per cent in each of the two following years. However, growth began to come down again in 2011–2012 and now the options open to the government are much more limited. A fiscal stimulus is a bit like an antibiotic. It is very effective when used for a short period of time. But if used repeatedly and over long stretches of time, the side effects tend to outstrip the benefits.
In India’s case, a large deficit is likely to fuel the inflation rate.
From the April 2016 issue of FHM India.
Spotted a mistake, or your photo used without permission? Report a correction














in your inbox