The Hunt For The iPad Killer

FHM tests new tablets and pits them against the iPad

The Hunt For The iPad Killer

The iPad has ruled the tablet roost long enough and frankly we’re quite sick of it. So we went scouring the market and got our hands on every tablet worth its apps, in search of the elusive one that will make Steve Jobs take notice.

Acer Iconia

Acer Iconia

We loved the rich metallic finish of the Iconia, but it took us a week of pretending to lift dumbbells at the gym to be able to confidently handle its bulk. The Iconia was one of the biggest tablets we got to play with, but there’s a pretty good reason for that. It’s like Christmas came early and stuffed the Iconia with some awesome connectivity options – full USB hosting, a dock connector, Micro USB syncing, a charging socket and Micro SD and Micro HDMI connectivity – all which adds to the muscle.

Read FHM India in the digital libraryEvery issue, every shoot, on TCG Media.

However, we were disappointed with the puny 16-GB onboard storage, which we soon exhausted with frantic downloads. The tablet does offer decent surfing speeds, but has a weird quirk – Apparently the tablet was downloading our movies at 51 Mbps and there’s nothing wrong with that except that our internet connection never went beyond 2 Mbps!

As a saving grace though, Acer had the good sense of including a physical rotation lock switch, which made it easier on our eyes (and arms). Its 10-inch WXGA capacitive touch screen is just as sharp and bright as the iPad, which means the onscreen action can be viewed from all angles and can easily be used outdoors in bright sunlight.

Games on the Iconia too look absolutely stunning. The NFS Shift, Let’s Golf HD and The Hero of Sparta come preloaded, but we unfortunately couldn’t join in the adventures of the Spartan hero because the game refused to load. The other two played without a hitch. Currently there aren’t a lot of games for honeycomb devices, however the existing games scale pretty well. The touchscreen keyboard too works like a charm. However, since the Iconia comes with a USB port we would have loved the option of hooking up a physical keyboard to write this review.

FHM verdict: It’s sturdy, robust and gives you just about all the multimedia options you need. If only it had been easier on our arms…

The Hunt For The iPad Killer

Olivepad

While not as heavy as the Iconia, it’s not as big either. In fact its 7-inch screen looked quite diminutive next to the Iconia. The all black surface looks rich and glossy and the edges carry a metallic finish embedded with all the expected buttons and slots. The user interface is well organised and quite easy to use. The G-Sensor however isn’t as smooth as we would have liked and took a few micro-seconds too long to find its bearing.

Gaming would have been a hoot on the Olivepad had the G-Sensor been smoother. It took some getting used to, but playing Angry Birds on a fully capacitive crystal screen made things interesting.

While we felt a little silly holding up the device and asking random people to pose, the 3mp camera did a decent enough job, but only when the light was good. The audio quality didn’t drive us crazy but who in his right mind would use a huge slate to make calls anyways.

This one gives great surfing speeds, the preloaded Zenga TV application allows you to watch your favourite channels on the go, and the inbuilt GPS sensor and the Map My India software can help you find your way back home when you’re too drunk to remember your lane; but it’s the 3G SIM card slot that won it for us.

FHM verdict: All in all, we’re convinced it’s quite a useful gadget to have in your backpack.

The Hunt For The iPad Killer

Motorola Xoom

Heard of the Gorilla Glass? It’s exactly what the name suggests – Rock hard, scratch resistant and perfect for butterfingers with a reputation for scratching and dropping their expensive smartphones. That’s what Xoom’s screen is made of and we love them for it.

The 10.1 HD widescreen display produced some of the sharpest images we saw. The picture quality almost made us regret our decision to purchase tickets for Singham because we may have enjoyed the movie more had we seen it on the Xoom. It’s also a hardcore gamer’s dream device and its Tegra2 Dual Core processor runs it at the speed of light. We felt that it was actually faster than the iPad (there we said it!).

We were also pretty satisfied with the image quality of both the front facing (2 MP) and rear facing (5 MP) cameras, which come with LED flash. However, the Xoom isn’t for all users and takes time getting used to. While most other tablets we tinkered with were quite intuitive, the Android 3.0 Honeycomb while amazing will give you a hard time in terms of navigation.

FHM verdict: Impressive operating speed, but its accelerometer is a little slower than the iPad. While not a deal breaker, we did find it a little odd.

Samsung Galaxy Tab

Samsung Galaxy Tab

Tipping the scales at 599 grams, it feels noticeably trimmer than both the iPad (633 grams) and Motorola Xoom (650 grams). Sure the tablet is made out of plastic unlike the iPad, yet it feels just as sturdy. Thankfully, with the launch of its latest version Samsung did away with the uncomfortably glossy back, which proved more slippery than a nymphomaniac girlfriend.

The Hunt For The iPad Killer

Obviously, the heart and soul of the Tab is its 10.1-inch TFT display, which while not as rich as some of the other tablets we used (including Acer) looks satisfyingly bright. While the 8 MP rear-facing camera with LED flash takes images that match the brilliance of its HD cousins, the 2 MP front facing centered atop suffices for those Skype calls.

Coming to software, it runs on the Android 3.0 Honeycomb and there are no custom apps or TouchWiz to sweeten the deal, which will annoyingly continue to stay that way. As Samsung themselves admitted, the Tab is simply a “Google Experience Device”, which isn’t half bad, but doesn’t come close to the 90,000 apps that can be downloaded to the iPad.

FHM verdict: While a nifty device, the only area where it actually overtakes the iPad is its weight. Minus USB and HDMI ports, it’s not even as practically useful as some of the others.

Asus Transformer

Asus Transformer

The transformer fits in nicely in your hands despite its size (10 inches), feels comfortably light and has really sexy curves. Plus, its textured back gives it a pricier look and ensures it won’t slip out of your fingers as it flings around wildly on your car dashboard when you’re overtaking the A-hole who refuses to give up.

The absence of a Micro-USB slot was a downer. Why would anyone use mini-HDMI over micro? Nothing wrong with trying to be different, but it should at least make sense. The MyCloud application is a pretty nifty addition and gives you the option of accessing digital content anywhere. A great physical space saving option, it earns the Transformer some brownie points.

The Hunt For The iPad Killer

FHM verdict: If you’re okay paying an extra 7k, then the keyboard attachment is a smart option and will increase the battery life to over 10 hours. Without the keyboard, the device will have to be recharged once its 7 hours are up.

A-Pad (The so-called Chinese iPad killer)

A-Pad (The so-called Chinese iPad killer)

At 5-feet away even Steve Jobs wouldn’t be able to tell the difference. A-Pad looks and feels almost like the real thing. Better yet, it doesn’t run on some dumb software like most Chinese clones and has the Android OS instead. When it was launched a year and a half ago, the 7-inch resistive touch screen was powered by Android 1.5. Later this year when the new version hit eBay, the screen size had been stretched by an extra 3 inches and ran on Android 2.2. The tablet is compatible with most audio, video and image formats.

What surprised us was that it’s equally proficient in opening Microsoft Office file formats. Additionally, it boasts of enough ports to house the Chinese navy. In addition to the regular Ethernet, it also has two USB and one HDMI port to connect the tablet to your HD TV.

If you’re looking for a device that allows you to multitask while offering a long battery life and lightning fast speeds – this one isn’t for you.

FHM verdict: To put it simply, it’s a neat purchase for anyone who’s looking for an inexpensive device to watch movies, read ebooks and surf aimlessly. However, it’s definitely not the iPad killer as its makers claim.

The Hunt For The iPad Killer

Notion Ink Adam

Notion Ink Adam

The device was launched with a lot of fanfare, but within a month half of its proud owners were baying for Rohan’s (CEO of Notion Ink) blood. Blogs and forums were created with the single-minded purpose of bringing down the company. Right about that time, we stopped being so proud of its Indian origins. Ironically, like Adam himself, the device too suffered from a lot of quirks that threatened to overshadow some truly remarkable innovations the makers came up with. It was also one of the few tablets we saw which didn’t attempt to emulate the iPad design.

With a rather robust, handsome look and a ‘rump’ that serves a variety of functions and holds the unit’s 3-cell battery in between with speakers on either end. Adam also plays host to a cool 3.2 MP swivel camera that can easily swap between front and rear facing orientations. Unfortunately, the overexposed images taken by the camera serve as perfect representatives of a brilliant but half-baked concept.

While theoretically Adam runs on Android 2.2, your geekiest friend would be hard pressed to identify it as such since the guys at Notion Ink wrapped the entire thing with a colorful interface called Eden. However, this customisation greatly limits the number of apps you can run on the device and the precious few offered by Adam are buggy and frustrating.

FHM verdict: This device requires rapid upgrades both in terms of hardware and software if it has any hope of surviving, let alone emerging as a genuine competition for the iPad.

BlackBerry PlayBook

BlackBerry PlayBook

In a quarter when Nokia is taken over by Microsoft and Motorola defects to the Google fold, you'd assume a company like BlackBerry vying for survival would stick to the basics. With the PlayBook, BlackBerry does exactly the opposite. It doesn't care that the iPad has addictive games, or that it's easier to find a 3G equipped tablet with 3G than it is to find gum on a street corner, it sends out the PlayBook in all its glory.

The Hunt For The iPad Killer

For a large part of our recent lives, the joke has been that there are only two kinds of people in the world – the BB guys and everyone else. The PlayBook – they want you to know from the very outset – isn’t for everyone. They probably look at it more like a platinum card for BB users than an independent tablet. That said, of the lot of tablets you see on the page right now, the PlayBook is an FHM favourite. Maybe that’s so because it’s the handiest of the lot or just the fact that we are one of the BB boys.

BlackBerry runs its own OS QNX on this 7-inch Hercules, which is reason enough for Mr Jobs to stop bad-mouthing tablets smaller than his. The PlayBook hosts something called the BlackBerry Bridge, which lets you access secure enterprise email. It’s surprisingly proficient in multi-tasking and has built-in viewing formats for spreadsheets and a nimble processor, a dual-core 1GHz – Basically, a huge bunch of things that made their smartphones the mainstay of the corporate world. Unfortunately for them, BB has come out of the boardroom and landed into the pockets of torn denims too, but the PlayBook hasn't.

It packs in a 3MP front-facing camera, a 5MP rear-facing one, a bright and crisp 1200x600 resolution screen, a light 425g body and all the typical gyro, accelerometer and GPS sensors, but with a strange aversion to staying faithful to WiFi connections. Phew! Even then, it's something we had strangely grown fond of till time came to return it.

FHM Verdict: The PlayBook might not be what Noah was to the great floods, but if the only time you change your phone is when BlackBerry updates its models, then you really can't do without one.

Dell Streak

Dell Streak

A great product killed by shoddy marketing and even shoddier tech support. We weren’t surprised when Dell pulled the Streak off its shelves at least in the States last month. Sales were way below expectation both in the US and in India and we can only hope that the next tablet launched by Dell survives the Apple juggernaut. However, since the product is still available in most Dell stores (at least it was the last time we checked) and the company promises to offer full product support to all Streak owners, you can definitely check this amazing gadget.

A hybrid device that gaily floats between a smartphone and a netbook, it’s super thin (10 mm) and lighter than most handheld devices. Its 5-inch multi-touch capacitive screen offers a super-sharp movie viewing experience, which makes it perfect for guys who travel a lot and want to stay updated with the latest antics of Salman. You can easily store more than three dozen movies as the Micro-SD slot allows you to expand its memory to 32 GB. Streak comes packed with 3G (translates into awesome browsing speeds), Wifi and most importantly Bluetooth 2.1 (think external keyboards, stereo heads and the rest of sheabang)

From the September 2011 issue of FHM India.

FHM
Team FHM

The FHM India editorial team.

Spotted a mistake, or your photo used without permission? Report a correction

More in Tech & Auto

All stories

Web Stories

Tap to watch · All web stories

in your inbox

The best stories, picked by our editors. You choose how often.

How often?
Unsubscribe anytime: click here to unsubscribe.