Two Extraordinary Gentlemen: Reece Shearsmith And Steve Pemberton

Two Extraordinary Gentlemen: Reece Shearsmith And Steve Pemberton

Meet the twisted minds behind The League Of Gentlemen, Psychoville and Inside No. 9.

One can only imagine the warped and distorted nightmares that must keep the creators of some of the most twisted characters ever to have graced our television screens awake at night.

Read FHM India in the digital libraryEvery issue, every shoot, on TCG Media.

“I’m quite scared of cows.”

“It’s horses I don’t like.” “It’s the slowness of cows though. They’re lumbering, with big teeth, and they’re lolloping towards you…”

“…Like zombies. Zombie cows – that would be the worst of all worlds.”

“It would, yes.” Oh. Right. Well, who could’ve predicted the night-time fears of Steve Pemberton (cow fearer) and Reece Shearsmith (distruster of horses)? From the minds of these two men were spawned serial-killing shopkeepers Edward and Tubbs Tattsyrup, hook-handed clown Mr Jelly, voodoo wife collector Papa Lazarou and more than 100 other equally disturbing characters.

Surely the writers and stars of legendary dark comedy series The League Of Gentlemen, Psychoville and, most recently, Inside No. 9, are wracked with downright demonic thoughts. Yet the two men sitting around the table in a boxy, bare-walled room adjacent to the FHM office on this chilly spring morning are charming (especially Pemberton), serious (especially Shearsmith), unfalteringly polite and almost disappointingly normal.

We know them today as one of the most established and best-loved partnerships in British comedy, but their enormous, multi-award-winning success was by no means an inevitability. Before The League Of Gentlemen came anywhere near becoming a cult classic, Pemberton and Shearsmith were just two jobbing actors from Blackburn and Hull, whose idea of a laugh was pretending to be the evil dwarf in Don’t Look Now. They had no natural place within the British comedy circuit. They were outsiders.

“I never believed that we’d end up where we’ve ended up,” says Pemberton, the greyer-haired, larger-boned of the two. “There’s an Oxbridge sort of comedian, coming through Footlights and Radio 4 and all that. Then if you went up to Edinburgh, it was all about stand-ups — a very male, aggressive, working-class movement. We never did feel like we belonged in any particular group.” Dark, horror film-inspired stories and creepy characters aren’t exactly the kind of thing you just slot into a stand-up night at a comedy club. “We tried,” says Shearsmith. “It was dreadful. Worst thing on the bill.”

The two of them, along with friends Mark Gatiss (who would go on to co-write ratings-smashing Sherlock, appearing as the eponymous detective’s older brother Mycroft) and writer Jeremy Dyson, started to run their own live sketch nights as The League Of Gentlemen — a knowingly ironic name for a group of northerners who were anything but. Without an agent or promoter, and through word of mouth alone, the show became an underground hit.

Two Extraordinary Gentlemen: Reece Shearsmith And Steve Pemberton

News of this unconventional troupe spread to the upper echelons of the BBC. They took a punt that there was indeed a place in the late ’90s television schedules, alongside tried-and-tested shows like Only Fools And Horses and One Foot In The Grave, for an innovative, genre-defying comedy series. In January 1999, 15 years ago, The League Of Gentlemen first aired on BBC Two, unleashing on the world the fictional northern town of Royston Vasey and its bizarre inhabitants. Among them were the hairy-chested, transgender cab driver Barbara and ‘accident prone’, animal-mangling vet Mr Chinnery; Victor Meldrew they were not.

After three series, a Christmas special, a slightly second-rate feature-length film and a slew of sell-out live shows, The League was disbanded (for the time being, at least – Pemberton and Shearsmith like the idea of a 20th anniversary reunion). Though the show’s four creators remained close, they spent the next few years pursuing their own projects. But the friendship and working relationship that Pemberton and Shearsmith had enjoyed was too strong to end there. “In The League Of Gentlemen, we fell into two writing partnerships, which were Jeremy and Mark, and me and Reece,” says Pemberton. “So it was quite natural that when The League Of Gentlemen came to an… on-going hiatus, shall we say, that we’d go, ‘Right, what are we going to do next?’”

Into the darkness

What did come next for the duo, though not until June 2009, was Psychoville, a dark comedy with such brilliantly sinister characters as serial killer-obsessed man-child David Sowerbutts, Beanie Baby-collecting blind millionaire Oscar Lomax, and a disturbed midwife (played by Dawn French) who treats a doll as if it were her own, real-life baby. Naturally, these are not your average, humdrum comedy characters. Most recently, in the superb series of short stories Inside No. 9, they further flirted with the boundaries of good taste by including a wheelchair-bound Make A Wish Foundation girl, a man with serious mental health problems, and allusions to child abuse.

Is it a case of anything goes? “I don’t think anything is off limits,” says Shearsmith. “Inside No. 9 is not that grisly or horrible, really. At nine o’clock on ITV there are horrific dramas, but you’re ready for it because the parameters are set, like, ‘OK, I understand that I might be shocked at this point.’ But if you’re operating from the BBC comedy department and suddenly you’re doing horrible things, the shock is more extreme, because you’re not expected to do it. All the drama is upped and all the moments of horror are heightened for someone who thinks it’s just going to be Mrs Brown’s Boys… because it’s not.” But isn’t offence a very subjective thing? “People used to say of The League, ‘I can’t watch it; it’s like a sitcom of Fred and Rose West,’ and other people would be like, ‘No, it’s like Mr and Mrs Tiggy-Winkle’,” says Shearsmith. So it’s just people’s tastes: some don’t find it dark, other people find it too squeamish. But we never set out thinking, ‘What’s the worst thing we can do?’” Even when they’re tossing a dog against a window and stabbing it to death with an umbrella…

Bedtime stories

The pair, who met at Bretton Hall College drama school in Yorkshire, both displayed some of the traits that would eventually lead them to Royston Vasey, and beyond, from an early age.

“I think I was a ghoulish little boy, into horror books and films,” says Shearsmith.

Pemberton agrees. “We had the same book, didn’t we, the Alan Frank book of horrors,” he recalls.

“Yeah, and Mark [Gatiss] did as well.” “And the Dick Smith horror make-up kit, where you could make your own horrific make-up and put it on your face.”

“Flex flesh…” says Shearsmith, clearly enjoying the nostalgic turn of conversation. “They were always rock-hard and would never glue on and looked shit. We were doing stuff that we now as parents would try to stop our children doing. I’ve liked magic since I was little as well, so I always used to do magic tricks. I don’t think my mum was ever like, ‘I’m a bit worried about Reece’ — I was quite quiet and I think she was pleased I wasn’t hanging around Threshers with a load of other lads drinking cider… I sat in reading The Pan Book Of Horror Stories.”

Ever since they were kids, the pair have surrounded themselves with unusual artefacts, and the mementos have become all the more macabre as their careers have progressed. Pemberton’s study is decorated with three severed heads — souvenirs from Psychoville — including his own face carved into a pumpkin. Shearsmith takes it to the next level: his specially commissioned heads, skulls and even the foetus of a werewolf, pickled in a jar, are kept in a secret attic room, concealed behind a bookcase opened by pulling a lever disguised as a bust on a shelf. “It’s amazing,” marvels Pemberton of his friend’s almost a parody, supervillain-style lair. “Like something out of Scooby-Doo.”

Two Extraordinary Gentlemen: Reece Shearsmith And Steve Pemberton

With their shared love of Hammer horror films and Tales Of The Unexpected (which would later inspire the format of Inside No. 9), it’s hardly surprising that, along with Gatiss and Dyson, they formed such a close friendship at drama school. Though remarkably, it wasn’t until several years after graduating, struggling to make ends meet as young actors and living on the dole, that they worked together for the first time.

Dead funny

Now, with more than two decades of writing and performing alongside each other, they’ve joined the ranks of the great comedy partnerships (though the last thing they’d do is describe themselves as comedians). Shearsmith — wearing a Victorian-style wool jacket — is the quieter of the two, rarely makes eye contact and comes across as a tad, well… odd, albeit in an endearing way. Pemberton, on the other hand, is smiley, warm and engaging. What they (and their creations) share is a uniquely British, gothic air, following in the frightful footsteps of everyone from Mary Shelley to Hammer horror; and an equally British deftness in treading the finest of lines that exists between funny and scary.

By toying with our expectations and our emotions in that way, what exactly are they trying to achieve? “I was watching Gogglebox the other night — which I think is a brilliant programme — but the idea that people will watch one of our shows like that, just talking all the way through it…” says Pemberton, shaking his head. “We wanted to create a piece of television that people would just watch, be completely engaged by and talk about afterwards. That’s what we want to achieve.” And they’ve succeeded: people don’t just talk about the shows afterwards, but faithfully parrot the catchphrases at every available opportunity.

“You’re my wife now, Dave”, “This is a local shop, for local people”, “Not now, Silent Singer”, “I did a bad murder”, and many, many more besides are still heard, or seen on T-shirts, across the nation.

Through thick and thin

Their fans know and love them as a peculiar pair, a gruesome twosome, a dastardly double act — OK, you get the picture — and so to the question every partnership traditionally must answer: do they actually get on outside of work? “No, not really,” they say together, exchanging a quick look as if to say, “Oi, that was my line,” before chuckling. “Yeah, we’re good friends,” says Shearsmith. “No one makes me laugh as easily and as deeply as Steve. That becomes the yardstick of what goes into the show: if I’ve made him laugh, or we make each other laugh, then it’s good.” Though they’re both keen to make clear that the process of writing comedy — which they do in their shared workspace, walking distance from their North London homes — isn’t all fun and games. “We kill ourselves laughing, but the craft of the writing is to shape it,” says Shearsmith. “People say, ‘Oh, me and my mates laugh down the pub all the time. I could do what you do. Don’t you just get pissed and write it all down?’ Of course not — can you imagine? It’s like pulling teeth. It’s proper work. The deftness is hopefully that it looks spontaneous — that’s the real magic trick.”

Picking up where the other leaves off, laughing at each other’s quips, gags and in-jokes — Pemberton and Shearsmith’s mutual admiration and long-time bromance is quite touching. “We wouldn’t do it if we were falling out all the time,” says Pemberton. “As actors and writers in our own right, we’ve got enough behind us to have careers, but the best stuff we both do is what we do together. We don’t have to be doing this, but we love it, and we choose to, and long may it continue.” Funnily enough, our thoughts exactly.

Inside No. 9 is out now on DVD. Happy Valley starring Steve Pemberton is currently airing on BBC One.

Macabre magic: the telly, films and people who inspired the Inside No. 9 creators

  • Reeves & Mortimer – Shearsmith: “I still find Vic and Bob the funniest people on television. They’re so inventive and dynamic; they never fail to floor me with their peculiar brand of comedy.”
  • Audition – Pemberton: “We don’t tend to look at other comedies for our inspiration. We’ll look to some Japanese horror film and apply it to a comedy. Then we’ve got something special.”
  • Mid Morning Matters – Pemberton: “The Alan Partridge series is set in a radio booth, and I found that absolutely gripping. If you set your own tone and your own pace, you draw people in.”
  • John Landis – Shearsmith: “John is such good company and has endless jaw-dropping stories. His love of film is so infectious too. He’s wonderful.”
  • The Haunting – Shearsmith: “This is a film that still frightens me. The director, Robert Wise, creates the granddaddy of haunted houses with Hill House. And you never see anything!”
  • The King Of Comedy – Shearsmith: “This is a favourite of mine. The study of fandom tipping into obsession is sublime. And even more potent and relevant today than in the ’80s.”

From the July 2014 issue of FHM India.

FHM
Team FHM

The FHM India editorial team.

Spotted a mistake, or your photo used without permission? Report a correction

More in Celebs

All stories

Web Stories

Tap to watch · All web stories

in your inbox

The best stories, picked by our editors. You choose how often.

How often?
Unsubscribe anytime: click here to unsubscribe.