All That It Takes to Court a Controversy
Nothing worthwhile has ever created a controversy… Read the article and you would know why.

The Hitler controversy

The trigger: A shop named Hitler
A readymade garments shop that opened last year in Ahmedabad was extensively written about in international media because of its name that reminded everyone about the dictator who terrorised the world killing 60 lakh Jews during World War-II. Rajesh Shah’s shop, HiTLER, became so infamous that the Consulate General of Israel, Orna Sagiv, during her visit to the city requested the Gujarat government to get the name changed.

What happened eventually: Shah refused to change the name claiming that his business partner's grandfather was nicknamed Hitler and this is what inspired the name of the store.
When the name Hitler created controversy

Zee Tv's show Hitler Didi
Nagpur's pool parlour Hitler's Den
Mumbai eatery Hitler's Cross
The Ice-Cream controversy
The trigger: The preview in Delhi restricted entry to international passport holders only

When the US based ice-cream company Haagen-Dazs opened its first store in the country at a mall in South Delhi, they put up signs around the area that read ‘Preview for international travellers’ and ‘Entry restricted only to holders of international passports’. The signs, which the company thought would tempt well-travelled people to drop in, met with huge criticism. Reportedly, an Indian was also turned away when he tried getting into the restaurant.
What happened eventually: While the company refused allegations that an Indian was turned away, Anindo Mukherji, MD of General Mill India, the company that markets the brand in the country was quoted as saying, “An error was made in the creative execution. It was the wrong choice of words and we regret the error.”
The Wall controversy
The trigger: Status update and Like button
Last year, when Shiv Sena called for a bandh during the funeral of its founder-leader Bal Thackeray, 21-year-old Mumbaikar Shaheen Dhada was arrested because of her Facebook wall post that said – “With all respect, everyday thousands of people die, but still the world moves on. Just due to one politician died a natural death, everyone just goes bonkers. They should know we are resilient by force, not by choice. When was the last time, did anyone showed some respect or even a two-minute silence for Shaheed Bhagat Singh, Azad, Sukhdev or any of the people because of whom we are free-living Indians? Respect is earned, given, and definitely not forced. Today, Mumbai shuts down due to fear, not due to respect.” Her friend Renu Srinivasan was also arrested for liking this post.
What happened eventually: People and institutions from all quarters heavily criticised Mumbai Police for arresting the girls and on January 31, 2013, even the court quashed all charges against the Thane residents.
The Hoarding controversy
The trigger: Hoardings showing Rahul Gandhi as Lord Shiva

At the ongoing Mahakumbh at Allahabad, a lot of hue and cry is being made about two hoardings, one of which compares the Congress vice-president, Rahul Gandhi to Lord Shiva. The Gandhi scion had recently said that power is poison and this is what inspired Congress leaders in Allahabad to come up with the hoarding. The hoarding reads, “Rahul baba, satta mein zehar hai. Theek hai. Par jo peeta hai zehar, wahi Neelkanth hota hai.” The second hoarding shows Congress president, Sonia Gandhi as Jhansi ki Rani Lakshmi Bai, who has been portrayed fighting enemies with Rahul tied on her back.
What happened eventually: While the hoardings received a lot of flak from other parties, BJP retaliated with a hoarding saying, "Modi Lao, Desh Bachao," and every other party followed suit.
The Column controversy
The trigger: SRK's op-ed in Outlook
Controversy’s favourite kid, SRK's column on what it takes to be a Muslim icon in India post 9/11, which he wrote in the year-end issue of Outlook gave half-read journalists a reason to convince their editors that they have a story to follow, publicity hungry political leaders an opportunity to gain mileage and hooligans a chance to do what they do the best – create a ruckus. Anyone who has read the column with an open mind, isn't infected with pre-conceived notions and doesn't believe in stereotypes could tell you the correct essence of the op-ed. The two excerpts from the column that were referred to as unpatriotic read – “I sometimes become the inadvertent object of political leaders who choose to make me a symbol of all that they think is wrong and unpatriotic about Muslims in India. There have been occasions when I have been accused of bearing allegiance to our neighboring nation rather than my own country – this even though I am an Indian whose father fought for the freedom of India. Rallies have been held where leaders have exhorted me to leave my home and return to what they refer to as my “original homeland” and "I gave my son and daughter names that could pass for generic (pan-Indian and pan-religious) ones: Aryan and Suhana. The Khan has been bequeathed by me, so they can’t really escape it. I pronounce it from my epiglottis when asked by Muslims and throw the Aryan as evidence of their race when non-Muslims enquire."
What happened eventually: Lashkar-e-Taiba founder Hafiz Saeed invited SRK to live in Pakistan. Even the Pakistani Interior Minister, Rehman Malik said that India should provide adequate security to the star. The remarks engaged leaders from both sides of the border and got them to mock each other.
The Film controversy
The trigger: A petition by Muslim groups

Kamal Haasan's dream project, Vishwaroopam, which was scheduled to release on January 11, 2013 first got delayed when cinema owners refused to screen the film simultaneously with DTH operators, and then when Muslim groups objected saying the film shows Muslims in a negative light.
What happened eventually: While media reports said that Haasan might lose his house because of the delay in the release, theatres that released the movie ran to packed houses in Tamil Nadu and the adjoining states raking in lots of moolah.
How the drama unfolded:
January 23: Following the protests by Muslim organisations in the state, Vishwaroopam is banned for two weeks.
January 24: Haasan moves Madras High Court against the ban. The court decides to take a decision by January 28 after watching the film on January 26.
January 25: Vishwaroopam releases worldwide except in Tamil Nadu. Screening had to be stopped in Hyderabad over possible security issues.

January 26: Malaysian home ministry bans Vishwaroopam a day after its release.
January 28: Madras High Court delays its order till the next day.
January 30: After Haasan threatens to leave the country the ban is lifted but two theatres in TN are bombed.
February 2: The Vishwaroopam controversy finally ends and the film is permitted to release with seven suggested cuts.
February 7: Vishwaroopam releases in Tamil Nadu
The Statue controversy
The trigger: BR Ambedkar's statue

When have statues not been controversial in India – Remember what happened during the last state elections in Uttar Pradesh? How the election commission spent crores to cover those elephant statues across the states? The latest is in Bangalore where Dalit groups have refused to allow Bangalore Metro people to temporarily shift Dr. BR Ambedkar's statue due to the construction of an underground metro railway in the technology hub.
What happened eventually: The government will attach the statue to a crane, so that it doesn't sink during the excavation work. According to other media reports, the statue might be enclosed in an iron cage.
The Toon controversy
The trigger: 1949 Ambedkar cartoon in textbooks
This is one of those numerous cartoons that have courted controversy in our country, but since this is the last one to do so, we thought it would be easy to recall. Around May last year, a cartoon on Jawaharlal Nehru and B R Ambedkar that was first published in 1949 was reproduced in a school textbook and created such a ruckus in the Parliament that the then HRD minister, Kapil Sibal had to apologise for the depiction that the netas believed insulted Ambedkar.
What happened eventually: The tension snowballed out of the parliament when a few men in Pune ransacked the office of NCERT adviser Professor Suhas Palshikar, who had justified the cartoon saying that it was published to help students get a better understanding of the subject.
Remember how the government banned porn-toon Savita Bhabhi without any announcements?

The all-girl band controversy
The trigger: Abusive comments on Facebook
The all-girl band from Kashmir, Pragaash, had to disband right after its debut concert in December in Srinagar following abusive comments on social media networks and demands from a top Muslim cleric that they stop performing. The controversy garnered huge support for the band but that was not enough to encourage the first Kashmiri girl band to continue performing.
What happened eventually: Three of the guys who hurled abuses at the band on social media were arrested while the police continue searching for other perpetrators.
The Art controversy
The trigger: Nude art
Art and controversy go hand in hand in India and an art gallery in New Delhi recently got a taste of that. The Delhi Art Gallery's latest exhibition – The Naked and the Nude: The Body in Indian Modern Art – which was showcasing the works of 160 artists including MF Husain and Raja Ravi Varma had to briefly shut when the women’s wing of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad opposed the showing saying that the art works treated women as commodities and that too at a time when the country is still recovering from the horrors of the recent gangrape case.
What happened eventually: Though a bigger protest was planned, the exhibition continued.

When nude got rude
Artists who have courted controversies for painting nude:
MF Husain for his Bharat Mata and Rape of India: He had to ultimately leave the country.
Pranava Prakash for painting nude actresses. He was even beaten up for showcasing the artworks at a gallery in Noida.
Artist Balbir Krishnan for his painting on homosexuality: He was attacked by a group of men who threatened him for holding a solo show at the Lalit Kala Akademi in New Delhi.
Say it with a fatwa
Don't dye your hair: Islamic seminary, Darul Uloom Deoband recently issued a fatwa against using hair dyes saying that the dyes prevent water from reaching the hair roots, and hence interfere with ablution.
Women can't be receptionists: Darul Uloom said women couldn’t appear before men without a veil, so they can't work as receptionists.

Swayamvars are un-Islamic: When Veena Malik was supposed to appear on Veena Ka Swayamvar, a fatwa by Majlis-e-Shura in Pakistan said that a Muslim girl can't hold a Swayamvar for herself because Muslims have nikaah.
Don't sell firecrackers: The fatwa was issued against selling and marketing of firecrackers because Darul Uloom believed that crackers are a waste of money, against Sharia law and people who waste money are brothers of the devil.
No blood donation: Replying to a question on participating in blood donation camps, Darul Uloom Deoband said that Muslims shouldn't donate blood because it's God who owns their body and not them. However, it did say that blood could be donated to save lives of near and dear ones.
Say no to skin tight clothes: One of the fatwas that started a nationwide debate on dress codes said that tight clothes should be completely avoided by girls and only loose apparels should be worn. Even denims and pajamas that are accompanied with a scarf are not allowed.
Contraception: A fatwa also says that couples should use contraception only after consulting a hakim.
Women can't travel beyond 48 miles from their house: A fatwa said that women can travel for longer distances only if they are accompanied by a male relative.
TV is haraam: Since it's a way of entertainment, TV shouldn't be watched.
Fatwa against Vande Mataram: A cleric said that since Vande Mataram literally means 'Mother (India), I bow to thee!’ Muslims shouldn’t sing it because they should only follow one god and that's Allah.
From the March 2013 issue of FHM India.
Spotted a mistake, or your photo used without permission? Report a correction

















in your inbox