Critiquing the Stars

Two of India’s most revered critics, Anupama Chopra and Rajeev Masand, tell us why it’s the golden period of Indian cinema.

Critiquing the Stars

How was 2018 in terms of films compared to 2017?

AC: It was an exciting year for Indian cinema. We are no longer watching just one kind of film. Directors are experimenting and audiences, too, are willing to watch these films. Look at how well Sui Dhaga, Padmavat and October did.

Read FHM India in the digital libraryEvery issue, every shoot, on TCG Media.

RM: 2018 has been a really good year. In the last couple of years, we have seen some improvement. Films which would have been ‘unviable’ three or four years back are not only being made, but are seeing great commercial success. Take Raazi or Stree for example. Story driven and character driven films are doing well. Films like Andhadhun and Sonu Ke Titu Ki Sweety didn’t seem like they could work, at least on paper, since they had no major stars. And yet, they did well. Regional cinema has been receiving a fair amount of attention, wherein several Bollywood production houses are remaking regional films into Hindi.

Do you think this trend will continue?

AC: It definitely should. Like I said, stories and filmmaking had been bogged down for quite some time. It is great to see new and fresh stories doing so well.

RM: Regional films have always been remade in Hindi. For Bollywood, success means doing good business. So, when the industry sees a film like Sairat and the kind of business that it did, it has a film with an intrinsic audience. Naturally, co-opting the film makes sense then. As long as films are good and easy to make, with the stories and sensibilities that are easily transposable, I believe that this trend will continue.

Where do you think Indian cinema is heading?

AC: We are heading towards some exciting times. What counts at the end of the day is the Box Office. A film needs to do well; only then will the directors and producers make such kinds of films. The audience is also responding extremely well to what the production houses are coming up with.

RM: We have some exciting times ahead of us, indeed. Thanks to the OTT (over the top) platforms like Netflix, and the like, the pressure to perform well at the Box Office has been reduced significantly. As a result, we are getting to see unusual storylines and plots. New kinds of films are being made. OTTs have allowed a kind of democracy and freedom. Take Shoojit Sircar’s October for example. It found a life beyond the Box Office, because that’s where the film’s audience was. The new golden period for cinema is here.

Critiquing the Stars

Are Indian award ceremonies really the sham that people often make it to be? And why are our filmmakers, so fascinated about doing well at the Oscars?

AC: Most Indian award ceremonies are entertainment shows essentially, whereas Oscars have a certain heft and pedigree to it. The Academy Awards and the Golden Globe Awards have the potential to impact one’s career. You will never find actors being endorsed as a Filmfare or an IIFA winner, whereas even if you are nominated for an Oscar or a Golden Globe, that goes in your resume. Each and every film that you do from then on, will present you in such a way.

RM: They are all a sham. They simply exist to generate revenues for broadcasters. Their aim is to deliver stars to the audience. Channels are ready to shell out more for a big star. However, they won’t pay that much for someone who acts really well, but is not an established star. As a result, the awards too often go to established stars instead of the ones who actually deserve them.

What according to you is the purpose of cinema today? Is it just for one’s entertainment or do films still have a bigger purpose in society?

AC: The main aim of cinema has always been to entertain. That function still is and will always be relevant. As for social messages in films, it is a personal thing. Films, after all, are extremely personal, so it won’t be correct to blanket them for everyone. Films made just for entertainment are as important as films that have a social message.

RM: There is no simple answer to this. It certainly has to entertain, as it has been the go-to option when it comes to entertainment, and continues to be so. I personally believe that it does not have to be an agent of social change. When it comes to art forms, people have different agendas. There has been a paradigm shift in the manner of consuming content, as well as the kind of content that is being consumed.

What are your views on this?

AC: It has been really exciting for me. For some time now, I have been purely a digital journalist. The kind of freedom, feedback from your audiences, and the interaction that a digital platform allows is unparalleled. Take 2 is my first podcast. I have really enjoyed the kind of conversations I have had. An audio-only platform like Saavn allows a certain kind of intimacy.

Critiquing the Stars

RM: Both of us have been film critics for 20 years now. There are several new exciting mediums, podcasts being one of them. For many years, people have suggested that we do a show together. Two critics, with completely different personalities, who look at things differently, have different tastes and opinions, will find that it is hard to find a common ground. This makes things interesting, and it shows in the podcast.

In 2018, which is that one film that you did not expect to do well, but were surprised at the kind of box office response that it received?

AC: I never think of Box Office collections when seeing a film. But, I was pleasantly surprised with the kind of business Stree did. I believe it did really well.

RM: I, too, was pleasantly surprised by Stree. On paper, a horror comedy should not have worked. But because it was well made, and it had great performances, it did well.

If you had to, which is that one film, Indian or otherwise, that you can gladly watch forever?

AC: I have a poster of Sholay signed by Amitabh Bachchan as my Twitter cover image. I guess that answers your question.

RM: It is difficult for me to select only one, so I will give you two. I enjoy Mr India very much, as it has so much joy. It speaks about friendship, love and it takes you into a different world. To me, it is one of the most quintessentially Bollywood films ever. Secondly, Mughal-e-Azam is another film that I thoroughly enjoy, for its all consuming beauty, love, conflicts, and of course, Madhubala.

From the January 2019 issue of FHM India.

FHM
Mehul Reuben Das

The FHM India editorial team.

Spotted a mistake, or your photo used without permission? Report a correction

More in Entertainment

All stories

Web Stories

Tap to watch · All web stories

in your inbox

The best stories, picked by our editors. You choose how often.

How often?
Unsubscribe anytime: click here to unsubscribe.