The Tragedy of Being Holmes
Of Richie’s effeminate Holmes, his new adventure called The House of Silk and BBC’s cellphone carrying Holmes…

When you look at the first certified book to come out of the Holmes canon in decades and it reminds you of Silk Smitha and Vidya Balan rather than the neurotic, gifted and addicted to banned stimulants detective – you know something somewhere has gone horribly amiss. Fortunately for Mr. Anthony Horowitz (the man behind The House of Silk), Guy Richie sent out Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law for an outing late last month ensuring that the book flew under the radar. Well, almost. Alas, the movie hadn’t yet released at the time of this issue going to press.
Truth be told, I am a Holmes nut/nuts about Holmes (whichever sounds less gay). I have forever lusted after the golden cufflinks with the Holmes silhouette in the checkered hunting hat and the pipe – even though I would never wear them. Baker Street in London is on my list of pilgrimage places second only to Latin America, Botswana, and Amsterdam, even though I frequently get confused about Holmes’ address – 221B or 21B. I’ve read most of the stories written by Mr. Doyle (barring one or two) and The Hound of the Baskervilles, like many other fanboys, is my favourite.

Tragically, Sherlock’s shrewd wit and subsequent popularity have also meant that there are more people standing in line trying to get in on the action than politicians clambering onto the Anna wagon. Even though the first Sherlock Holmes made by Madge’s ex was a great movie, as the reformed druggie Jr’s second outing will undoubtedly be too, but there was nothing Holmes (or for that matter Madge’s ex-hubby) about the movie.

While flicking channels some 15 days ago, I found BBC Entertainment running a contemporary version of Holmes. Dr Watson has just returned from the war in Afghanistan with a limp and a prettier Holmes is suddenly averse to wearing his hat, or smoking onscreen.
In Silk… on the other hand, the author walks heavy with the burden of history on his shoulders – and has managed to pack an insane amount between every comma – making sentences like we do at FHM. But then we aren’t certified by the Doyle estate.

Somewhere between Doyle’s stories and now, several authors have attempted to take the story forward beyond that duel with Professor Moriarty (works only when you say it in your best Sean Connery accent). In one, he was supposed to have been in Tibet, while more recently an author tried to give an account of Watson from imagined letters sent to his parents by Dr Watson – tragically much like Horowitz’s attempt and the interpretation on BBC, they keep you as interested as the third sequel of Krrish would.
Don’t get me wrong – I am by no means against ‘contemporary interpretations’ of classics – do what you want with The Tale of Two Cities or the like, but must Holmes be subjected to the torture of interpretations as well?
On another note though, my favourite moment in Holmes was when a friend seeing Lord Blackwood publicly hanging from London Bridge remarked, “They’ve copied the idea from Shahenshah.”
From the January 2012 issue of FHM India.
Spotted a mistake, or your photo used without permission? Report a correction

















in your inbox